Grassroots Push for Student Loan Forgiveness for New and Beginning Farmers
Grassroots push for Student Loan forgiveness could remove barrier to new entry farmers
This article was written by our friend Kimberly Hart
I recently contacted my U.S. elected officials to propose that farming become one of the areas of employment eligible for Public Service Loan Forgiveness. I’m hoping that many young, beginning and new farmers struggling with student loan repayment will contact their representatives as well. The following are the nuts and bolts of the request but you can find a sample letter that can be tailored to your own personal circumstances at https://doc.google.com/View?id=dcgxkn99_3dzh3w7c9
The centerpiece of the College Cost Reduction and Access Act of 2007, is the Public Service Loan Forgiveness option that allows individuals employed in certain public service areas to have any remaining loan debt discharged after 10 years of repayment. It also allows participants to utilize the Income Based Repayment schedule during those 10 years to inspire people to go into under-served and low earning, not-for-profit or community sustaining fields. Farming, with it’s aging participants, low on-farm income earning capacity and importance to local communities, regions and the country at large, is a perfect employment area to be added to the list of professions eligible for forgiveness.
Income Based Repayment (IBR) prevents payments on federal student loans from exceeding 15% of a borrower’s disposable income above 150% of the poverty level. This plan also allows for the government to subsidize 3 years of interest payments and to have any remaining debt erased after 25 years. It is the combination of IBR with Public Service Loan forgiveness that might allow more young people to look at farming as a viable career.
For example, under the most common farm financial circumstances (based on USDA statistics):
A farm family of four, with on-farm income of $10,000 and student loans totaling $45,000 at an interest rate of 6.8%:
> under Standard 10-year repayment they would pay $517 a month, totaling $62,143.00
> under IBR they would pay $0 a month, leaving a debt that would
accrue interest over 25 years to well over a $100,000.00, greatly impairing their ability to
borrow money in the future
> under IBR, with Public Service Loan Forgiveness, they would pay $0 a month, but with
the government subsidizing the first 3 years of interest, they would only accrue 7 years
of interest before forgiveness – greatly reducing their debt load and allowing for
borrowing that could help grow their business or help their own children go to college
Under IBR with Public Service Loan Forgiveness, the same family:
>with an income of $20,000, would pay $0 a month
>with an income of $40000.00, would pay $87 a month, with total repayment equaling $10,400.00
>with an income of $70000.00, would pay $460 a month, with total prepayment equaling $55,200.00
This repayment schedule, Income Based Repayment coupled with Public Service Loan Forgiveness, is the best option for young, beginning, and new entry farmers. We need to reach out to our elected officials and help them recognize how beneficial Student Loan Forgiveness could be to the profession of farming and the future of agriculture.
If you are in need of assistance with repaying or dispatching your student loan, or simply care about the future of agriculture in this country, please take the time to contact your representatives and let them know that they can help build financial security for a new generation of farmers, and by extension their communities, by adding farming to the Public Service Loan Forgiveness plan.
IBR link https://studentaid.ed.gov/PORTALSWebApp/students/english/IBRPlan.jsp >
PSLF link https://studentaid.ed.gov/PORTALSWebApp/students/english/PSF.jsp>
U.S. Representatives link https://www.usa.gov/Agencies/federal.shtml >
Kimberley Hart is a Brooklyn based artist who has been active in the sustainable food movement in NY city. After years of supporting local farmers, she and her husband are in the process of transitioning into full-time farming. They are currently exploring the feasibility of starting a diversified farm, with a focus on pastured livestock in Eastern TN.
I agree this is a great idea and have no doubt it would help some of the young people entering farming here in western NC.
Unfortunately, changes like this will simply be “rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic” unless the fundamental threat posed by the proposed inappropriate, self-styled “food safety” federal regulation is stopped by substantially revising the legislation. S 510, and the even worse HR 2749, will not only cause those already becoming sustainable farmers to be unable to make a full-time living farming but also won’t materially improve the overall safety of food in the US. In fact, because the regs will be more expensive and difficult for sustainable ag to implement than industrial ag, S 510/HR 2749 will further tighten industrial ag’s control of our food system.
I know this to be true because after 14+ years working to revive local, healthy food her in western NC, I have had to spend the last 6 months endeavoring to understand this complex situation and legislation.
For more info or to help, please write me at healthyfoodcoalition@gmail.com or call me at 828/669-4003 8 – 8 Eastern Time, Monday – Saturday.
Harry,
Thanks for writing. Though I support the effort for student loan forgiveness, I am also sympathetic to your concern about “food safety” legislation.
I know I post a lot, and it’s not easy to catch all of my blog entries, but I have put up 3 posts regarding the “food safety” legislation issue in roughly the past two weeks alone:
Article, Update and Action on Food Safety Legislation – Posted Feb. 1st. https://beginningfarmers.org/article-update-and-action-on-food-safety-legislation/
Food Safety Bills Reach too Far, Cost too Much – Posted Jan. 26th
https://beginningfarmers.org/food-safety-bills-reach-too-far-cost-too-much/
Food Safety Legislation Editorial: The Bad, The Ugly, The Inevitable, and the Uncertain – Posted January 15th.
https://beginningfarmers.org/food-safety-legislation-editorial-and-update-the-bad-the-ugly-the-inevitable-and-the-uncertain/
I would invite you to please read them and let me know if you think that there is information missing that should be aired, of if there is anything you believe to be erroneous within them. I have tried hard to invite dialog on this topic, to keep readers up to date, and to encourage political action on this issue. I hope that we can keep this discussion going.
Taylor Reid
Hi, I was curious as to any developments on your efforts to include farming under the Public Service Loan Forgiveness program. What can be done to help the cause? I am a recent graduate that now operates the family farm, and am working to pay back my loans.
I’ll look into this more. There has been a lot of interest from many people. If you want to send me a personal e-mail at beginningfarmers@gmail.com to remind me to get you the info, that would be helpful. I’m juggling a lot of bowling pins right now.
Taylor
I think what you are attempting to do is great. I farmed for 12-years before starting college. While in school,.my father got sick andhad to stop farming. I graduated at the end of ’08, and have failed at finding promising employment. I was wondering if this was possible in North Carolina? I want to start back farming, but have been reluctant to look into getting loans to begin farming; being that I have student loans